punk ipa is it as good is it was?

BeerCat · Oct 2, 2017

simon12 said:
I forgot to say its the only thing worth drinking in many Greenking pubs.

I made the mistake of trying a greenking IPA once. I have not really drunk that much Punk IPA but last bottle i had i thought it had less aroma that i remembered and the taste seemed milder. Perhaps it was not very fresh.

Brew_DD2 · Oct 6, 2017

DoctorMick said:
I had a bottle last week for the first time in ages and I really enjoyed it, not sure how much of a difference freshness makes?

I think that's probably it. They've recently spoken about implementing a cold supply chain to ensure that their beer is as fresh as possible once it reaches its destination. How it is stored once it reaches stores is another matter, and pretty much out of their control.

There are many things you can say about BrewDog but they do really care about the quality of their beer.

foxbat · Oct 6, 2017

BeerCat said:
I made the mistake of trying a greenking IPA once

Good heavens why? Had the pub run out of beer?

BeerCat · Oct 7, 2017

foxbat said:
Good heavens why? Had the pub run out of beer?

Yes and i regretted it the first sip! :mrgreen:

AdeDunn · Oct 7, 2017

BeerCat said:
Yes and i regretted it the first sip! :mrgreen:

Could of been worst bud, could have been Toby.....:whistle:

serum · Oct 17, 2017

I think the hop taste has changed but I can't work out if that's my palate or the beer. It seems less crisp now and more musty.

I think it depends on the hop harvest each year though. There have been years where home brewers say certain hops taste a bit **** and have the onion taste I keep banging on about. One I started tasting that it ruined a lot of beers!

Jabo1428 · Apr 2, 2018

I know this thread was from a while ago but I've just had a bottle (first for some time) and it's not as I remember. Less aroma, lower hop flavour and less 'punch'.

jceg316 · Apr 2, 2018

Jabo1428 said:
I know this thread was from a while ago but I've just had a bottle (first for some time) and it's not as I remember. Less aroma, lower hop flavour and less 'punch'.

I haven't had punk for a while now, but my friend had it for the first time in a long time as well and asked me if they changed the recipe for the same reasons. He wasn't sure if the recipe changed or his tastes have as punk is quite middle of the road now.

Sheepish · Apr 2, 2018

FWIW ...I had a free pint of it in one of their pubs, first I’ve ever had, and the aroma was like putting your nose in a bag of hops, rather bitter (obvs) but smoothly bitter, and all in all a very nice refreshing pint.

dad_of_jon · Apr 2, 2018

the 5.4% in spoons shows a further sad decline. still i'll take one for the forum when i'm in brewdog cardiff on saturday to see if its any better. :laugh8:

simon12 · Apr 3, 2018

I tried it a few times recently in the weatherspoons (after not having it for ages) and thought its lost alot of flavour even to how remember it not being that great in the past.

anders · Apr 3, 2018

dad_of_jon said:
the 5.4% in spoons shows a further sad decline. still i'll take one for the forum when i'm in brewdog cardiff on saturday to see if its any better.

Make it a free one :beer6:

https://brewdog1million.com

BeerCat · Apr 3, 2018

Seems less hoppy to me and darker.

Sheepish · Apr 3, 2018

This was mine, don’t know how that compares for colour...

krispn · Apr 3, 2018

I was never a big fan of it - I think a lot of Brewdog beer had a very 'brewdog signature taste' - it might have been the Simcoe hop, it might have been something else - but I could have told you I was drinking a brewdog beer in a blindfold test.

I think it's an OK pint now - maybe it has toned down a bit or my tastes have changed where its not as offensive as I previously found it.

dad_of_jon · Apr 3, 2018

anders said:
Make it a free one :beer6:

https://brewdog1million.com

thanks for the heads up!

on the site atm... timing out at present :-(

Alside101 · Apr 3, 2018

I remember it been quite hazy when i first had it but the other weekend at my local spoons it was crystal clear

prog99 · Apr 13, 2018

Had my free one last night. Mrs prog99 was convinced it was nanny state. I'm sure its better in bottles/cans?

As an aside, Very big moose was very good.

soupdragon · Apr 13, 2018

Last time I was in spoons I had some punk, I also got a pint of shipyard pale and I actually preferred the shipyard.
I was shocked how bland the punk was

Cheers. Tom

BeardedMag · Apr 13, 2018

I couldn't agree more with the fact it's went bland. When it was first released it was floral, hoppy and you knew you were drinking a decent beer. Had a pint in Brewdog Newcastle last week and I asked if they'd poured me the wrong one it was that bland!

punk ipa is it as good is it was?

Help Support The Homebrew Forum:

Landlord.

Mint Choc Chipster

Landlord.

Landlord.

Member

Landlord.

New Member

Landlord.

Active Member

Beer designer

THBF Sponsor

Active Member

Landlord.

Active Member

Regular.

Beer designer

Landlord.

Landlord.

Senior Member

Well-Known Member

Similar threads

Join the conversation!

Join today and get all the highlights of this community direct to your inbox. It's FREE!