NEIPA brew/dry-hop advice

The Homebrew Forum

Help Support The Homebrew Forum:

This site may earn a commission from merchant affiliate links, including eBay, Amazon, and others.

bmass96

Active Member
Joined
Nov 28, 2018
Messages
82
Reaction score
18
Hi folks,

I've not long just tried my 2nd batch, which was a 1 gallon all-grain NEIPA...sadly nowhere near as nice as the first batch I did (which was an extract IPA brew).

I noticed on the brew day that there was a LOT more excess sediment left over in the FV when I transferred it, I'm assuming I went wrong along the line given that it was my first all-grain...perhaps I didn't sparge quite right...I don't know. The end result was vile anyway. It also turned out tasting like a more disgusting version of my first brew, despite them being different types of IPA? Can anyone help me think of where I went wrong? I can't think for the life of me.

Also, dry-hopping! The kit said to add it 4 days *before* fermenting has finished. Does this sound normal? I read elsewhere you wanna dry hop when the fermentation is still active!? I also used pellets and dropped them straight into the FV, assuming that was correct.

Any advice would be appreciated!

Cheers! acheers.
Ben.
 
dry hopping - adding 4 days before fermentation has finished. aunsure....
how can you know in advance when fermentation has finished ??? - it's variable - it sounds like a typo - you would normally dry hop after fermentation has finished because fermentation drives off hop aromas.
 
dry hopping - adding 4 days before fermentation has finished. aunsure....
how can you know in advance when fermentation has finished ??? - it's variable - it sounds like a typo - you would normally dry hop after fermentation has finished because fermentation drives off hop aromas.

Cheers!
 
Not on a NEIPA though, there's some interesting biochemistry going on dry hopping early.

I'm happy to accept that but how can you know in advance to dry hop 4 days BEFORE fermentation has finished other than a rought guess - it could be anywhere from a few days to a few weeks. For my beers 2 - 3 weeks
 
What kit was it? What was your process.
You want to dry up after 2-3 days and then again post fermentation.
What did you get with the kit?
 
What kit was it? What was your process.
You want to dry up after 2-3 days and then again post fermentation.
What did you get with the kit?

Hi Leon,

This is the kit I used:

https://www.brewstore.co.uk/4-5l-new-england-ipa-all-grain-beer-kit#product_tabs_additional_tabbed

The the process was pretty standard (not sure how much detail I need to explain), but I'm sure where I went wrong was with the sparging. I didn't actually add the required amount of water back in while sparging - just didn't feel right. I guess with it being my first all grain recipe it just didn't feel right.

The way I actually did the dry hop was 4 days after fermentation had finished.

I don't do any sort of water treatment either, not quite at that level yet so I wonder whether that was a factor in it tasting similar to my first batch.

The kit itself literally was just the ingredients listed...

Cheers,
Ben.
 
I wouldn’t put it down to the sparge. Could be that you dry-hopped a bit early, how long did you dry hop for in the end? I’ve previously dry-hopped after a week, for a week before bottling which worked ok.

What was your timeline over all? Did you do 2 weeks fermenting, 2 carbing and 2 conditioning or something else?
 
I suspect they mean dry hop 4 days after fermentation starts - a lot of NEIPA brewers believe adding hops when fermentation is still active adds to haze/mouthfeel/hop character of the style.
 
I wouldn’t put it down to the sparge. Could be that you dry-hopped a bit early, how long did you dry hop for in the end? I’ve previously dry-hopped after a week, for a week before bottling which worked ok.

What was your timeline over all? Did you do 2 weeks fermenting, 2 carbing and 2 conditioning or something else?

It was 10 days fermenting, then 4 days and a dry hop, then after another 2 weeks I tried it. I used pellets and put them directly into the FV.

To be fair I'm still quite new to this scene so yeah, I followed the instructions as much as I could aunsure....
 
I suspect they mean dry hop 4 days after fermentation starts - a lot of NEIPA brewers believe adding hops when fermentation is still active adds to haze/mouthfeel/hop character of the style.

Ah right...in which case I didn't quite do it right! I'll have to revisit the notes. Cheers!
 
It was 10 days fermenting, then 4 days and a dry hop, then after another 2 weeks I tried it. I used pellets and put them directly into the FV.

To be fair I'm still quite new to this scene so yeah, I followed the instructions as much as I could aunsure....

Ah right...in which case I didn't quite do it right! I'll have to revisit the notes. Cheers!
Your instinct to follow the instructions is the right one. While they might require a bit of deciphering, it is still the best way to proceed.

One note - if I understand correctly, this brew was in your fermenter for 4 weeks. For most beer styles, that would not be a problem at all. But NEIPA is a bit of an exception, and is best drunk very fresh, as it is prone to oxidation/staling. It could be that it tasted lousy because it was oxidized.
 
Back
Top