I think the reasoning behind it is there are those wishing to make good beer, and those who just make beer. At the end of the day those just wishing to make beer will go their way while those who wish to make a better beer will follow the proven science of brewing.
Have you ever thought of getting a water report from an independent source?
Although the water report should be made available on request from the authority.
https://byo.com/article/the-power-of-ph/
Sterilising comes in two parts, the first part is an alkaline clean, if you don't do that no amount of acid based steriliser is going to work.
http://www.milkthefunk.com/wiki/Quality_Assurance
Best thing about mistakes is what they teach us, happens to all of us and helps to be a better brewer. It isn't the equipment you use which makes you a better brewer, it is yourself. But for me the Brew Devil with a few tweaks is what I use.
I have been thinking along similar lines, (automated stirrer) it is the only real way to equalise the temperature of the mash throughout, plus there are other benefits too.
https://byo.com/mr-wizard/mash-stirring/
I haven’t said I don’t like his videos, I have only watched a couple they are very good for new brewers. It is when one branches out and starts to think critically that brings up some contentions. As a new brewer we are all impressionable so we believe what we read or see. But we have to also be...
I was a porn movie star under the name of Maxwell Hung. I wasn't really but I like to tell people that. I don't think telling someone qualifies the master brewer suggestion.
If I was a qualified master brewer I would be working in a brewery raking it in, instead of sitting in an accounts clerks...
I did read on another thread,'There is no wrong way to make beer'.😂
I think quoting David Heath and Marshall Schott, two home brewers as an authority on brewing science beggar's belief.
What Charlie Bamforth says I have read before volatile's are driven off in two ways the boil and the ferment, I haven't got a pressure vessel yet. When I do that is what my aim is, to carbonate the beer towards the very the end of fermentation by the application of some pressure.
You aren't alone, it is mentioned a lot on forums, I will only force carbonate if I am in a hurry. Otherwise I prime with dissolved sugar, problem is CO2 will have to be introduced for the pour. That is one of the advantages of the bladder inside the keg. The beer conditions in the bladder and...