racking to secondary too early?

The Homebrew Forum

Help Support The Homebrew Forum:

This site may earn a commission from merchant affiliate links, including eBay, Amazon, and others.

Braufather

Landlord.
Joined
Aug 23, 2016
Messages
1,804
Reaction score
651
Location
NULL
Ive always just used the one FV but as I’m going on holiday a week on Friday and want to brew this Friday it would mean the brew sitting on the trub for 3 to 4 weeks so not ideal.

Instead I was thinking of racking it of the trub into a second FV before I go but am concerned about taking it off the test cake too early. It’s a hoppy semi hazy American pale.

So can I rack it to a secondary after 6 days? Will enough yeast go over with it to clean up the fermentation?
 
Ive always just used the one FV but as I’m going on holiday a week on Friday and want to brew this Friday it would mean the brew sitting on the trub for 3 to 4 weeks so not ideal.

Instead I was thinking of racking it of the trub into a second FV before I go but am concerned about taking it off the test cake too early. It’s a hoppy semi hazy American pale.

So can I rack it to a secondary after 6 days? Will enough yeast go over with it to clean up the fermentation?
Easily
 
3-4 weeks in primary is not a problem. If it were me I'd just leave it.

i used to do that regularly too but a few times live experienced a sort of veggy taste as a result. It might be because take most of the trub into the FV from the kettle.
 
I've had beer sit on the yeast/trub for 4 weeks before. Beer tasted delicious. But your process may be different, and racking to a secondary certainly won't hurt it
 
I always rack from the FV into a second container (I use a polypin on its base with an airlock in) after 3-4 days when fermentation has died down but not stopped. A lot of yeast drops out in thr first few hours and I leave it in that container for about a week until I bottle from it. This is a process known as dropping which used to be recommended before cold crashing became popular.
 
I very rarely move my beer to a secondary fermenter. I’ve often left mine on 3 weeks with no issues.
Personally I’d leave it alone and enjoy your holiday, but either way would be fine.
 
Very Very rarely do I rack to secondary as I believe it is not essential and just gives more chance of oxidisation especially with hoppier/Neipa beers.
I would leave it myself, when you say you got a vegetative taste have you taken the hops out or do you just throw them in the boil which means some can be transferred and 3to4 weeks is a long time if hoppage is in there
 
If racking to a secondary FV when should I add finings to help clear the beer?

Thanks in advance
 
I rack to a secondary routinely. I then add primings and finings at bottling. That way you know you have enough yeast still in suspension fir it to carbonate.
 
I would leave it myself, when you say you got a vegetative taste have you taken the hops out or do you just throw them in the boil
These days I just chuck them in and a lot of the trub goes into the FV. As I aim to keg within two weeks it’s not been an issue.

Going to brew day before I go so it will be 3 weeks before kegging so yes I think I will need to dust off my spider as well as leaving most of the dregs in the kettle!
 
I do not know if it is causing a issue I suppose it depends on the hops some are supposed to be more vegetative than others. I have dry hopped for 1 week and never had a issue but if you normally do 2 weeks and its been ok and it works for you then carry on but as you said 3 weeks may be too much so spider it is or hop bags so that they can be removed minimising the hop debris transfer
 
Back
Top