Veganuary.

The Homebrew Forum

Help Support The Homebrew Forum:

This site may earn a commission from merchant affiliate links, including eBay, Amazon, and others.
Hmm. He states that your not getting adeqate protein on a vegan diet. Beans and rice make a complete protein. Id like to know what studies he's basing his claims on. I've never heard of the banting diet but I can make a guess he's just promoting it
I suppose what is "adequate" is very dependent on a person's lifestyle. If they sit on their ass all day at work and spend their free time watching TV then an adequate amount of protein is probably very low. If they're a gym bunny or are trying to build muscle mass then I would say it's very difficult to get adequate protein on a vegan diet.
 
The Vegan Butcher. That's a great name for veggie food products...but then some soppy tree hugger would find it inhumane to be butchering a load of Maris pipers or a free range cabbage...
 
I eat more veg than anyone in our house the greener and darker the better, I love dark cabbage spouts spinach, I probably eat more veg than meat, the only veg I don't like is parsnips horrible things
I like my vegetables too, actually, I do like parsnips too. Even turnips. I would probably eat more vegetables, if it wasn't for my wife, she likes fruit more than vegetables. Which makes it sometimes difficult to balance our weekly recipe. But she's going back to WW now, which normally makes it easier for me to eat more vegetables.
 
Why call it sausage roll or the latest vegan steak bake, just call them vegan roll or vegan bake, very clever of Greggs to keep the meat theme to boost sales
I believe the use of "sausage, burger,nuggets, steakbake" is being looked into by the relative advertising authorities as they do not contain meat in a terminology that infers it has meat in the product. Do not shoot the messenger
 
I suppose what is "adequate" is very dependent on a person's lifestyle. If they sit on their ass all day at work and spend their free time watching TV then an adequate amount of protein is probably very low. If they're a gym bunny or are trying to build muscle mass then I would say it's very difficult to get adequate protein on a vegan diet.

The requirement for protein isnt actually that much (for the averge bloke its about 56g, which is actually quite easy to get in. Most vegs has a small amount of it in (how do you think big powerful mammals like bison or gorrilla get so big - they do have to spend an awful lot of their time eating though) and you then just have to go for the 'big hitters' like beans and nuts. There's also stuff like tofu if you want to eat that
There are plenty of vegan bodybuilders. I'm not sure exactly how they do it because I'm not one of them but it seems doable

Edit - bodybuilders seem to consume a lot of protein shakes. A lot of these protein powers come from whey but you can get pea protein. So perhaps that's one way they do it?
 
Last edited:
It's the "agree with me or be automatically bad" lot I really don't like...I can switch my TV off,you can't switch this current tide of pc Nazis off because of fear.

That's what they want you to think! I'd say corporate advertising is far more insidious the a few hippies telling you not to eat meat because it's cruel
 
The requirement for protein isnt actually that much (for the averge bloke its about 56g, which is actually quite easy to get in. Most vegs has a small amount of it in (how do you think big powerful mammals like bison or gorrilla get so big - they do have to spend an awful lot of their time eating though) and you then just have to go for the 'big hitters' like beans and nuts. There's also stuff like tofu if you want to eat that
There are plenty of vegan bodybuilders. I'm not sure exactly how they do it because I'm not one of them but it seems doable

Edit - bodybuilders seem to consume a lot of protein shakes. A lot of these protein powers come from whey but you can get pea protein. So perhaps that's one way they do it?
Yeah for the average person, who is pretty sedentary, it wouldn't be too difficult. For those trying to add muscle mass the rda is 1g/lb bodyweight which for a 15st bloke like me is 210g of protein. That would be difficult or very expensive without milk and whey protein. The other factor is that not all proteins are created equal, pea protein is significantly inferior to whey protein not to mention a lot more expensive. I know there are vegan bodybuilders (don't get me started on Vegan Gains :mad:) but it's really tough for them to get the same quantity and quality of protein.
 
Anyway now christmas is over I now identify as a Turkey/Nutroast
 
Yeah for the average person, who is pretty sedentary, it wouldn't be too difficult. For those trying to add muscle mass the rda is 1g/lb bodyweight which for a 15st bloke like me is 210g of protein. That would be difficult or very expensive without milk and whey protein. The other factor is that not all proteins are created equal, pea protein is significantly inferior to whey protein not to mention a lot more expensive. I know there are vegan bodybuilders (don't get me started on Vegan Gains :mad:) but it's really tough for them to get the same quantity and quality of protein.

Even if your pretty active and not sedentary (like myself) It's fairly easy to get enough protein. Even if you goal is just to get fit or play a sport it's still relatively easy (at a non elite level - there are plenty of elite level sports people who are vegan so that shows it's doable). What your talking about of course is bodybuilding which which is quite a small percentage of the population.Bodybuilding isnt easy as Im sure you know and I would think if your dedicated enough to spend hours in a gym wanting to build muscle , plus your a vegan, you'd simply put the effort in to find a way.

What on earth is vegan gains?
 
Even if your pretty active and not sedentary (like myself) It's fairly easy to get enough protein. Even if you goal is just to get fit or play a sport it's still relatively easy (at a non elite level). What your talking about of course is bodybuilding which which is quite a small percentage of the population.Bodybuilding isnt easy as Im sure you know and I would think if your dedicated enough to spend hours in a gym wanting to build muscle , plus your a vegan, you'd simply put the effort in to find a way.
Not bodybuilding specifically but anyone who wants to get bigger or stronger, which if you've been in a gym recently seems to be a lot of people. Anyway, my point was not that it's impossible but simply that for certain people a vegan diet makes it considerably more difficult or expensive to get enough protein.
 
Not bodybuilding specifically but anyone who wants to get bigger or stronger, which if you've been in a gym recently seems to be a lot of people. Anyway, my point was not that it's impossible but simply that for certain people a vegan diet makes it considerably more difficult or expensive to get enough protein.

I don't go in gyms to keep fit. I've got my recumbent ;)

So we agree. Getting enough protein and building muscle on a vegan diet is not impossible
 

Latest posts

Back
Top