Bleach as a sanitiser.

Help Support The HomeBrew Forum:

stevebea

New Member
Joined
Aug 6, 2019
Messages
11
Reaction score
5
Hi and thanks for letting me join.
Please forgive my lack of knowledge as i have just started my first cider kit.
I sanitised with Jsan but found soaking everything for 30 minutes a bit of a pain.
Has anyone any thoughts on the bleach and vinegar no rinse method and do you have to let everything dry before using.
Many thanks in advance.
Steve
 

kelper

Old Salt
Supporting Member
Joined
Mar 4, 2019
Messages
1,317
Reaction score
416
Location
Highlands
Any sanitiser needs some time to work. I fill my fermentation bucket and add some *Fred n Flo tablets normally used for sanitising baby bottles. Into the bucket goes the siphon, some swing top bottles the measuring cylinder and hydrometer along with the lid and any other bits n pieces. After 15 minutes I pump the liquid into my pressure barrel. The first lot gets a quick rinse and then I start brewing. While I wait, I am heating the cans of extract in a sink of hot water. So there's little or no hanging around once you have a routine.

* https://www.tesco.com/groceries/en-GB/products/302169753 a pack of 56 for 75p. Will treat 2.3 litres per tab.

You can use household bleach IF it's non-perfumed AND non-thickened.
 
Last edited:

strange-steve

Quantum Brewer
Joined
Apr 8, 2014
Messages
4,050
Reaction score
2,788
Location
Galle Crater, Mars
Bleach is the best sanitiser there is. Don't waste your money on Starsan or carbonation drops.
I suppose it depends on what is meant by "best". Yes bleach will do a better job of killing bacteria, wild yeast, mould, spores etc. but it requires longer contact time and needs rinsing off afterwards. Starsan isn't a disinfectant so is less effective, but its sanitising power is good enough for our purposes, requires very little contact time, is no-rinse and so generally much easier to use.
 

An Ankoù

Landlord.
Joined
Feb 2, 2019
Messages
2,582
Reaction score
1,330
Location
Brittany, France
I must say, to be fair, that I've never used Star San. On the other hand, I have used Five Star Beer Stone (BS) Remover and it categorically doesn't work. I tried the suggested dilution and worked up to full strength. hardly a mark.
I then tried supermarket strength hydrochloric acid and that didn't make much of a mark, either. In truth I didn't expect it to. Undiluted bleach seemed to work a little better, but not much and I'm now in the process of superannuating my ancient Hop and Grape Seven Gallon buckets in favour of Speidel fermenters. My point being, that if one product from this bunch of snake oil vendors doesn't work then I'm not going to waste my dosh trying another one.
 

PhilBrew

Regular.
Joined
Jun 24, 2019
Messages
215
Reaction score
127
Location
South Cheshire
Hi Steve
Has anyone any thoughts on the bleach and vinegar no rinse method and do you have to let everything dry before using
... I use a very weak bleach and vinegar mixture as a no rinse sanitiser, following the "recipe" that Charlie Talley (the guy who invented StarSan) described on a Brewing Network radio podcast a while ago ... I've only used it on bottles, because like kelper explains above once you've got a routine it's not too arduous to rinse :?: ... so everything else gets a soak in stronger (but still weak, 10-15ml per ltr) bleach solution, then rinsed before use ... but bottling is arduous enough without having to rinse steriliser out of bottles :?:

The Charlie Talley "recipe" equates to (he explained it in US fl.oz. and US gals) 1.5 mls of bleach, mixed in 1 ltr of water, then 1.5mls distilled (white) vinegar added ... NEVER mix the bleach and vinegar together directly, that's how you make chlorine gas, which is poisonous, always mix in water!!!!!! ... but you need to bear in mind that he was talking about bleach at 5% hypochlorite, and Tesco/Asda/Morrison's Value Thin Bleaches vary from 3.5-1.0% hypochlorite, so read the label and calculate the correct amount :?: ... and for the mix to be effective, it relies on lowering the pH of the mixture (with the acidic vinegar) so you need to use low alkalinity water :?: ... and on the podcast he explained (if I remember correctly) that when mixed like that it is as effective (if not better) than StarSan, with a similar contact time :?:

I've been using it for around 3-4 years now, and can't remember any infected bottles in that time :?:

Cheers, PhilB
 

Rodcx500z

Landlord.
Joined
Jun 10, 2019
Messages
1,667
Reaction score
710
Location
on the island
I must say, to be fair, that I've never used Star San. On the other hand, I have used Five Star Beer Stone (BS) Remover and it categorically doesn't work. I tried the suggested dilution and worked up to full strength. hardly a mark.
I then tried supermarket strength hydrochloric acid and that didn't make much of a mark, either. In truth I didn't expect it to. Undiluted bleach seemed to work a little better, but not much and I'm now in the process of superannuating my ancient Hop and Grape Seven Gallon buckets in favour of Speidel fermenters. My point being, that if one product from this bunch of snake oil vendors doesn't work then I'm not going to waste my dosh trying another one.
Hi An, my routine is, plastic fvs, pb's, bottles pet, a good scrub with warm water and fairy liquid a really good rinse with cold water then a dose of Milton rip off 30 mins another rinse and away I go, my personal view is over the years the advertising boys have convinced us we will die if we don't do this or that, people are terrified of germs, I once saw a family at alton towers spray the whole table in a café and then put that gel crap on their hands before they ate a pizza even my daughter who was seven at the time commented on it she is 21 now and still alive, go to spain and other hot countrys take an early morning walk and you will smell bleach
 

stevebea

New Member
Joined
Aug 6, 2019
Messages
11
Reaction score
5
Hi An, my routine is, plastic fvs, pb's, bottles pet, a good scrub with warm water and fairy liquid a really good rinse with cold water then a dose of Milton rip off 30 mins another rinse and away I go, my personal view is over the years the advertising boys have convinced us we will die if we don't do this or that, people are terrified of germs, I once saw a family at alton towers spray the whole table in a café and then put that gel crap on their hands before they ate a pizza even my daughter who was seven at the time commented on it she is 21 now and still alive, go to spain and other hot countrys take an early morning walk and you will smell bleach
Very much agree.
Kids won't have a chance of developing any sort of immune system in this nanny state.
A very paranoid society.
 

Peter Scandlyn

Active Member
Joined
May 10, 2017
Messages
85
Reaction score
16
Location
NULL
@An Ankoù - snake oil vendors! Having a laugh, have to agree completely.

@stevebea - just in case you go the bleach way, don't leave it in prolonged contact with bleach.

Personally, I'm a bleach person and rinsing after contact has always been part of my game.
 

stevebea

New Member
Joined
Aug 6, 2019
Messages
11
Reaction score
5
Thanks for all the replies.
There's a lot to learn and i'd be struggling without all your help.
Cheers Steve.
 

simon12

THBF Sponsor
THBF Sponsor
Joined
Aug 28, 2014
Messages
2,447
Reaction score
693
Location
Edenbridge Kent
I must say, to be fair, that I've never used Star San. On the other hand, I have used Five Star Beer Stone (BS) Remover and it categorically doesn't work. I tried the suggested dilution and worked up to full strength. hardly a mark.
I then tried supermarket strength hydrochloric acid and that didn't make much of a mark, either. In truth I didn't expect it to. Undiluted bleach seemed to work a little better, but not much and I'm now in the process of superannuating my ancient Hop and Grape Seven Gallon buckets in favour of Speidel fermenters. My point being, that if one product from this bunch of snake oil vendors doesn't work then I'm not going to waste my dosh trying another one.
I think beer stone needs a nitric acid based cleaner or just nitric acid, if my memory is correct I once spoke to a brewer that had an issue with it and this worked great https://murphyandson.co.uk/store/brewery-hygiene/145-nipac-b-30-kgliquidhz.html but is to hazardous for most home brewers.
 

Drunkula

Landlord.
Joined
Nov 30, 2017
Messages
1,663
Reaction score
1,124
I had so many batches of beer ruined by the 'no-rinse' Charley Talley acidified bleach. It's not that you can't trust his methodology it's that you can't trust thin bleach to be thin bleach. Sometimes you buy it and it is thin, buy the same bottle from the same manufacturer some other time and it'll have some surfactant left in it. Shake the bottle and see if there are foamy bubbles, if there are it's not thin bleach and you have to rinse.

Star San is always Star San.
 

Chippy_Tea

Administrator.
Administrator
Joined
Mar 17, 2013
Messages
27,747
Reaction score
6,299
Location
Ulverston Cumbria.
snake oil vendors! Having a laugh, have to agree complete
AA said in his post he has never used Star San his reference to snake oil was about other products, Star San has been discussed here many times and I cannot remember one saying its doesn't work.
 
Last edited:

An Ankoù

Landlord.
Joined
Feb 2, 2019
Messages
2,582
Reaction score
1,330
Location
Brittany, France
Ha. This debate is getting as entrenched as those about restoring capital punishment, Spurs v Arsenal and the dreaded "B" word. Each to his own, I say. For me it's a case of "once bitten, twice shy" and have a serious grump about wasting £9 on so called Beer Stone remover. So I shall continue to rinse out my cauldron with maidens' tears, at the crossroads, under a full moon while whistling the tune to Donny Osmonds' "Puppy Love". Never failed me yet so why change!
And with that, I have nothing more to say on the matter (unless I forget).
 

Rodcx500z

Landlord.
Joined
Jun 10, 2019
Messages
1,667
Reaction score
710
Location
on the island
Ha. This debate is getting as entrenched as those about restoring capital punishment, Spurs v Arsenal and the dreaded "B" word. Each to his own, I say. For me it's a case of "once bitten, twice shy" and have a serious grump about wasting £9 on so called Beer Stone remover. So I shall continue to rinse out my cauldron with maidens' tears, at the crossroads, under a full moon while whistling the tune to Donny Osmonds' "Puppy Love". Never failed me yet so why change!
And with that, I have nothing more to say on the matter (unless I forget).
An as long as the ale is good does it matter acheers., one ? what is beer stone
 
2
Group Builder
Top